Divetrac: Wow, where did you get that from? They sell battery replacements for about $30, complete with the tool needed to take apart your iPod. I can think of 3 or 4 stores I've seen the replacements at around here. FYI, my old 3rd gen iPod is going on 3 years of daily use and still humming along perfectly. Maybe this <a href='http://www.ipodbatteryfaq.com/'>iPod Battery FAQ</a> will help?
Creative & Dell do have ok players, but there are absolutely zero accessories available for them. Ever walk into a Best Buy and look at the add ons you can get for an iPod verses the Zen or DJ? No comparison. Also, I'm not sure, but can you play Audible.com books with them? That was a big decision in going iPod for me.
Explorer better than iTunes for updating a mp3 player? This is a bit like arguing that manual roll down windows & manual locks are vastly superior to power windows & locks.
Sure, there is some simplicity to manually copying songs over, but with the iTunes automatic model it keeps everything up to date without you needing to remember to manually copy over that latest song. It also lets you build "smart lists" which do things like track your most played songs, remembers when you last heard songs and lets you build self updating play lists which keep your music always fresh.
Check out <a href='http://playlistmag.com/help/2005/02/brillplaylist/'>playlistmag.com</a> or <a href='http://www.smartplaylists.com/'>smartplaylists.com</a> for some ideas on just how powerful a feature smart lists are.
I'd have to think REALLY hard before buying a player that wasn't an iPod now days. Trendy or not, they got to the top for a reason. Until Apple screws up that formula, they'll be getting my money.
*edit to fix link*