TJR,
i have had all three brands of GPS and thought the Magellan was the worst of the bunch. I also had a Garmin iQue3600 which was a GPS build into an Palm Pilot PDA. Great GPS, great maps, very accurate, but the map updates were expensive and the device occasionally acted weird and would occassionaly show me somewhere else then my current location? I used to have reboot the GPS and let it find my location which often took several minutes...:angry:
For the money, I think TomTom gives you the most bang for your buck with the widest selection of GPS units to fit in everyone's price range. In fact I think Garmin and Magellan have started to make more economical GPS units to compete with TomTom.
A few years ago there was a comparison done on one of the TV news morning shows that had three drivers with three different GPS unit all depart the same NY city location and follow their GPS instructions to their destination across town. Each GPS gave a different route and yet all three drivers arrived at the same location within 1 minute of each other.
They that all three units would get you to your destination but the user preferences were often the key factor as to how you were routed, either the shortest route, the fastest route, etc, toll roads, freeways, etc... Often, the user's preferences made very little difference except on longer trips.
The bad part about my Garmin was that you had to send it to the factory if the battery went bad and there was a flat fee of $75 to change the battery??? Now you can buy a whole new GPS for what they want for just the battery replacement...:angry:
Also, in the past, Garmin and Magellan had much better mapping software than the early TomTom's, but then newer TomTom's have caught up and I think there are only two companies that provide mapping software for GPS and they are all about the same and the screen presentation is the only factor that differs between the brands.:grin:
I just added a few GPS units with prices from TigerDirect.com Some are new and some refurbished One is a link to a similar unit that you posted but it is new, with lifetime maps for only $99.
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=6498324&Sku=T529-0132
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/category/guidedSearch.asp?CatId=2372&name=GPS-Navigation
...Rich