Theoretical question to make a point, and pull this topic together:
Had you rather buy a vehicle with, say, 35,000 miles, and no maintenance records,
or a vehicle with 120,000 miles with meticulous maintenance records???
I would prefer the latter! Again, depends on many personal driving habits (I.E.,
one 500 mile trip is better than 100 - 5 mile trips). But you still have the same 500 miles
on the odometer, for overall mileage purposes.
But you have no way of knowing this detail without some kind of maintenance record.
I know, myself, I don't document every 5 mile trip I make, but I do document longer
trips, all maintenance records, etc... Always go with a maintenance record, if available.
And then do the math on the average miles-per-year, and so forth!