Eddie, same end result no matter which you switch from side to side...
The reason most do it the other way is so that all the tires get equal time at each location.
For example, you go to Goodyear and they do it as I explained above, then if you went to Joe Mechanic and he did it your way... The issue there would be that all 4 tires would be right back to where they were before Goodyear did the rotation...
Here is my best example.
C,D
A,B (before any rotaion)
B,A
C,D (After Goodyear roation)
A,B
C,D (if the front get swap around as opposed to the back after Goodyear did it the other way)...
Thus, no real change.