Since I'm taking a break from studying evidence....
Each in turn:
Bumper. I love the ARB front bumper with winch. ARB makes some bad-ass offroad gear.
Fender molding/trim. With larger tires and a larger lift, the huge fender trim could work. But, it needs to be matched to the plastic trim better.
Paint. The two-tone cab area is lame in that the guy used black. Most vehicles should stick to two primary colors and very light use of a third for accents. I'm not sure how I'd change it, but black on top, white in the middle, and two shades of silver for the fenders and trim don't work at all.
Badges. Crappy and tacky. Why not just add Corolla to it?
Hood scoops. To each their own. Some love them, some don't. I am in the second category when they're not functional.
Windshield visor with lights. This would be great if it was an old-school Mack or Peterbilt, or even an F-250 duallie. But, some trucks are too small to rock them, and I think the ST is one of them.
Bugshield and Window Trim. No beef with me.
Jack on the Roof. Is that what I think it is? It sure looks like a scissor jack. Am I seeing things? Maybe he threw a ground-pounder where the backseats used to be. If it's a jack, it's stupid. I will accept a Hi-Lift (since it's a lifted Trac), but not a scissor jack. Edit: It looks to be the roof rack from the van behind. Okay then.
Front skid plate. Not bad. Going for the off-road look/use, and it's pretty important.
In its defense, it has pretty low miles and for $9,000, it's reasonable.