Hello all.
Last year I was faced with the issue of needing to replace my 07 ST. I just put new tires on it, rebuilt the front end, and replaced quite a few parts on it to make it last. But at the end of the day, the transmission was going out and once I turned the CEL off after fixing one thing, it would turn on a day later for something else. The constant repairs began dragging me down - I don't use shops and do all the work myself. I couldn't see myself replacing the transmission just to have more engine issues or possible timing chain problems. After 10 years, I had to let it go and it was a sad day.
The Ranger was one of the vehicles I was looking at. My father had Rangers for as long as I could remember and they were a good truck. But as it was mentioned here, the new ones have a lot of things lacking and I couldn't justify paying a huge price to be dissatisfied. I ended up with a 19 F150 5.0/10 speed. Compared to my 07 ST 4.0 that needed gas every 5-7 days, I now go 14+ without stopping at a station. That is one of the upsides, kind of. The 10 speed seems to be somewhat jerky sometimes. I have to feed the 5.0 89 fuel otherwise it pings. The truck turns wider and is harder to fit into parking spots where I could just whip the ST in. It also has fixed rear glass which was a real bummer.
After 10 years owning the 07 ST, I was very used to it. I miss the rear glass that comes down to a vent of full position. I loved that I could remove the radio and put in something aftermarket. I miss the storage compartments in the bed, among many other things. Whether it be the F150 or the Ranger, everything is more electronic, right down to the parking brake. You can't change radios because they are two piece - one box is the radio in the dash and the second piece is the display. The radio and options are all coded into the truck's computer so you can't even change radios from lets say OEM without Sirius to OEM WITH Sirius easily without entering into, and changing some codes.
My intent is not to bash the 150 or the Ranger, people are going to love or hate things as they see fit. I guess my point is once you find something good and become used to it, it is hard to be satisfied by something different. All these newer vehicles have their pros and cons but the ST was really one vehicle that fit all my needs comfortably. Sure, the bed wasn't the largest but it worked, it was a good, smooth ride. With some good ol' maintenance and under hood checks, aside from being hit by someone on the front passenger side, it stayed out of the shop those 10 years whereas I know people with brand new cars going in and out of the shop multiple times. Mine simply just wore out and I don't have the time like I used to, to crawl under it for every little thing.
IMHO I think it will be difficult for any long term fans of the ST to find something that is directly comparable. You might get close which if you do, that is a good thing. Maybe one day they'll remake them.