Caymen, please don't take this the wrong way, but I agree that a reskinned, 4-door Ranger would be an appealing vehicle and mechanically and structurally a "dream truck" for someone like you. And, I recognize the value you would place on a such a vehicle.
But the reality is that's all "substance", and we live in a world in which "form", not substance is what sells. Much of the traffic and debate on this website is about form vs. substance and perception vs reality. Well, the reality in this world is that form and perception are EVERYTHING.
If consumer reports says that Toyota is higher quality than Ford, then THAT is the reality of it....evidence to the contrary is moot. If the marketplace says that the Ridgeline is a better vehicle than the ST due to sales and overall customer satisfaction, then again, that is the reality, individual points of comparison are again moot.
Whether or not the ST has a stiffer frame, or more horse power, or is more "truck like" than the Tacoma or the Ridgeline, is therefore moot when determing which vehicle is "better." Because, "better", ultimately has to mean "sells more".
People largely don't know what they want in a vehicle or for that matter even in a truck. This I firmly believe. A majority of the trucks and SUVs on the road aren't being put through the paces and for the purposes they were designed, yet they were SOLD to a marketplace that accepted them willingly and came to demand them.
People's needs and matching those needs to the substance of products stopped about 50 years ago in this country. Today, and for some time now, people are SOLD products, they don't BUY them.
And, once we ALL recognize this then we will start to realize that American companies need to learn how to SELL.
TJR