Religion question, Difference between between Protestantism and Catholicism?

Ford SportTrac Forum

Help Support Ford SportTrac Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Kevin Palmer

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2001
Messages
9,349
Reaction score
3
Location
Madison, OH
Basically, I need to write a paper on this. Small, only 150 words and then reply to others that post questions about my post.



Being that I was raised Methodist, the above religions I have littler personal knowledge of.



If you have a moment, can you give me your opinion of the differences.



Thanks much, I appreciate your time.
 
OK, this is a thread I'm going to have to keep an eye on. I suspect there will be some pretty good wisecracks going here quite soon! :rolleyes:
 
That should do it..



http://www.religioustolerance.org/chr_capr.htm



http://www.gotquestions.org/difference-Catholic-Protestant.html







Todd Z
 
I am not asking what is right and wrong here people... LOL



That would be WAY TOO DANGEROUS ground to venture into, just looking to get info on the differences and or the perception of the differences...
 
The Protestant relgion was started by Martin Luther to "Protest" the power of the Roman Cathlic church and the power of the Pope.



The Protestant relegion removed a lot of the restictions added to the Catholic religion by the Pope, like celebicy by the clergy, clergy could not marry, etc.



...Rich
 
I thought Catholics considered all the other Christian denominations to be "Protestant", including the Baptists, Presbyterians, Lutherans, Methodists, etc.
 
dreman is correct. All Christian denominations not part of the Roman Catholic Church are regarded as Protestant. Each of these denominations had some disagreement (protest) against some teaching of the Catholic church and felt so strongly that they broke away from the mother church.
 
I believe Martin Luther was initially upset with the idea of 'Penance' in the Roman church. In other words by deeds or,more heinously, by money, paying for the remission of sins. If you read the famous '95 Theses' you see that that was the gist of them.



I am a Protestant formerly Roman Catholic. I would say the biggest difference involves salvation. Protestants believe that Jesus Christ payed for our sins on the cross and faith in Him and His work for us gains salvation. In the Roman Catholic Council of Trent there were many anathemas declared like this one that is appropos of what I wrote above:



"If any one saith, that by faith alone the impious is justified; in such wise as to mean, that nothing else is required to co-operate in order to the obtaining the grace of Justification, and that it is not in any way necessary, that he be prepared and disposed by the movement of his own will; let him be anathema."



Protestants do say that by faith alone we are justified. Roman Catholics add works to that. I can't off hand think of a good site but I would lookup Martin Luther and see what information you can glean. Admittedly a site about Martin Luther will probably be biased towards the Protestant side but would still give a good view of the differences.



 
Last edited by a moderator:
There is a good explanation at the link below. The schism which created the Eastern and Western Churches isn't the beginning of Protestantism. As Dennis stated, this movement began with Martin Luther, though some could make a case that the Eastern Orthodoxy is also Protestant in nature. Pope John Paul II tried to bring them back into the fold, and made some good gestures in that direction, but almost 1,000 years of separation is a difficult obstacle to overcome.
 
You could write about the Microsoft takeover attempt of the Catholic Church:



Microsoft Bids to Acquire Catholic Church



By Hank Vorjes

VATICAN CITY (AP) -- In a joint press conference in St. Peter's Square this morning, MICROSOFT Corp. and the Vatican announced that the Redmond software giant will acquire the Roman Catholic Church in exchange for an unspecified number of shares of MICROSOFT common stock. If the deal goes through, it will be the first time a computer software company has acquired a major world religion.



With the acquisition, Pope John Paul II will become the senior vice-president of the combined company's new Religious Software Division, while MICROSOFT senior vice-presidents Michael Maples and Steven Ballmer will be invested in the College of Cardinals, said MICROSOFT Chairman Bill Gates.



"We expect a lot of growth in the religious market in the next five to ten years," said Gates. "The combined resources of MICROSOFT and the Catholic Church will allow us to make religion easier and more fun for a broader range of people."



Through the MICROSOFT Network, the company's new on-line service, "we will make the sacraments available on-line for the first time" and revive the popular pre-Counter-Reformation practice of selling indulgences, said Gates. "You can get Communion, confess your sins, receive absolution -- even reduce your time in Purgatory -- all without leaving your home."



A new software application, MICROSOFT Church, will include a macro language which you can program to download heavenly graces automatically while you are away from your computer.



An estimated 17,000 people attended the announcement in St Peter's Square, watching on a 60-foot screen as comedian Don Novello -- in character as Father Guido Sarducci -- hosted the event, which was broadcast by satellite to 700 sites worldwide.



Pope John Paul II said little during the announcement. When Novello chided Gates, "Now I guess you get to wear one of these pointy hats," the crowd roared, but the pontiff's smile seemed strained.



The deal grants MICROSOFT exclusive electronic rights to the Bible and the Vatican's prized art collection, which includes works by such masters as Michelangelo and Da Vinci. But critics say MICROSOFT will face stiff challenges if it attempts to limit competitors' access to these key intellectual properties.



"The Jewish people invented the look and feel of the holy scriptures," said Rabbi David Gottschalk of Philadelphia. "You take the parting of the Red Sea -- we had that thousands of years before the Catholics came on the scene."



But others argue that the Catholic and Jewish faiths both draw on a common Abrahamic heritage. "The Catholic Church has just been more successful in marketing it to a larger audience," notes Notre Dame theologian Father Kenneth Madigan. Over the last 2,000 years, the Catholic Church's market share has increased dramatically, while Judaism, which was the first to offer many of the concepts now touted by Christianity, lags behind.



Historically, the Church has a reputation as an aggressive competitor, leading crusades to pressure people to upgrade to Catholicism, and entering into exclusive licensing arrangements in various kingdoms whereby all subjects were instilled with Catholicism, whether or not they planned to use it. Today Christianity is available from several denominations, but the Catholic version is still the most widely used. The Church's mission is to reach "the four corners of the earth," echoing MICROSOFT's vision of "a computer on every desktop and in every home".



Gates described MICROSOFT's long-term strategy to develop a scalable religious architecture that will support all religions through emulation. A single core religion will be offered with a choice of interfaces according to the religion desired -- "One religion, a couple of differen
 
Having been raised Catholic, now am more Pentecostal/Baptist there are some significant differences.



Both have their good and bad points. No "religion" is perfect as "religion" is a doctrine of Man, not of God.



Faith is of God.



Some of the differences include but are not limited to:

- Confession of Sins to another Man

- Speaking in Tounges

- Abstention of Marriage by Clergy

- Ceremony/tradition

- The use of the Bible in actual services

- The use of Wine in the eucharist (my church is HEAVY against alcohol... we use grape juice....<sigh>) and alchohol in general

- The view of Homosexualism in SOME protestant doctrines







There are many more. These are the big ones that come to mind. Be careful of the "www.religioustolerance.org" website above as there is a lot of dubious information on it, but there is a lot of information that can lead to further research and understanding. There are a lot of statements that are made that are claimed to be fact, when in reality they are a localized cleircal opinion, not a stance the Church as a whole takes. There are seveal items in the chart that say the Protestant demoniations deny that is not necessarily the case.



Whatever you do, consider the source. If you're looking at a Catholic website, know there is a slant. If you're looking at a RHEMA website or a Southern Baptist website or Jerry Falwell's website, know that. There are plenty of place for information. Some websites will contradict each other. The more research you do the better off you'll be and the more informative your paper.



 
Coastie,



Dennis and R Shek do a decent job on pointing out some of the differences. (Though I will point out that I would not call the use of grape juice as part of communion. Most protestant churches I know use wine). Biggest ones being Salvation by grace vs by works, the legitimacy of the Pope, and what is going on with the Eucharist/Holy Communion.



One of the tough things that you will find is that "Protestant" is a very general term. As someone mentioned, Lutherans, Methodists, Baptists, etc. are all "Protestant" churches. While the Catholic Church is essentially unified through the pope, there is a very wide range of beliefs within protestant churches.



Even the individual denominations have divisions. I am Lutheran, but more specifically, I am Wisconsin Synod Lutheran. There are also the Evangelical Lutheran Synod, Missouri Synod, and the Evagelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA). All of them, while Lutheran, are a little different.



I know the Wisconsin Synod website has some very useful reference and question and answer sections. www.wels.org.
 
And remember what my fundie-Christian neighbors say: "Catholics aren't Christians!"



(Just kidding of course I don't subscribe to that...I find my neighbors pretty bizarre).



TJR
 
Wow - this is a really strange topic to find here. Well, I have been doing a bit of research on this topic myself, just for personal edification. A great resource about Catholicism is www.catholic.com. A couple others are catholicapologetics.org and catholicweb.com.



Just keep in mind what has already been mentioned - don't read a fundamentalist website to learn about Catholicism, and vice versa. There are THOUSANDS of web pages out there created by fundamentalists that do nothing but spread lies about Catholicism. I've had to wade through their tin-foil hat wearing, conspiracy believing, hate-mongering tripe to find the valid resources. There are plenty of good resources out there about Protestantism as well. If you need some suggested reading, I have some books I could refer you to.



One big difference between Protestants and Catholics is that the Protestant bible removed books that the Catholic Bible has in it. They state that these books were not written by Jews, and were not properly divinely inspired, so therefore can't be in the bible.



Oh, one more note - you'll hear a bunch about the Council of Trent and various other issues (anathemas, indulgences, etc.). Make sure you read the current Catholic position on these things before you form an opinion. Don't let a Catholic teach you about Protestants, and don't let Protestants teach you about Catholicism. That's like trying to push rope - it just don't work.
 

Latest posts

Top