I bought a set of Sport King AT, 265/75R16. They're a more aggressive style, I think, even than most other ATs. They're made by a company called Cavalier. I had never heard of them before, but they're a Michelin brand. That eased all concerns I had about buying something I didn't know. $600 installed was attractive, too.
They are basically the same as the BF Goodrich (also a Michelin brand I learned). They were about $50/tire cheaper and my tire guy guaranteed I would like them or he would swap them out for another tire. I didn't absolutely need to save that much money at the time, but why not? He's someone I really trust and he wasn't going to charge me anything if I changed my mind. He was absolutely right.
They're great off road, but I don't gather that is what you're looking for. I'd also say they are good on the road, too. Indescribably better than the stock Goodyears. I've never hydroplaned, they're quiet for an AT, seem to be wearing evenly (only 5k mi. so far), and look aggressive. I don't know for sure, but I'd assume Cavalier makes other tires that may suit your needs better if ATs don't interest you.
Just my $0.02. Just sharing my experience. All the others seem like good choices, too.
