Obviously, there are going to be critics of both the iphone and the Droid.
I've been with Verizon since the were GTE in '98 and personally, I've been monitoring any and all internet buzz I could find on the Droid for months now. . . trust me, I want the Droid to be better than the iphone for some of the obvious reasons (5.0 camera with flash, adobe flash, removable battery & memory, it's not AT&T, etc.), but I am an avid apple user with iMac, itouch, time capsule, etc. and I've also been following the "Verizon iphone" rumors and I want them to be true too.
I think the main thing to consider is that you are comparing apples and oranges . . . Apples are way better than oranges to some people and oranges are way better to others.
Just my two cents . . . the Droid, with Google Maps/Voice and Android 2.0, has come a long way but there is still a lot of room for improvement. . . . The real question is, do you want the "best phone" available with the worst coverage, or do you want the second best phone with the "best coverage"?
Personally, I've had to stop myself from stopping in a couple of times and impulse buying the Droid, but I'm going to hold off until the 1st or 2nd quarter of 2010 and hold my breath for a Verizon iphone or at least a 2nd Generation Droid.
Also, the best & non bias reviews available are on engadget.com and gizmodo.com
Btw, for what its worth, one of the iphone-loving-gurus on engadget.com compares all phones he reviews to his beloved iphone. He is so impressed with the Droid, that he stated that he's tempted to get a second personal phone line with Verizon, just to get the Droid.
One other thing to consider is that Verizon just increased their contract cancellation fee to $350 . . . . not to say that AT&T won't be soon to follow.