OK--Convince me. TIVO or ReplayTV?

Ford SportTrac Forum

Help Support Ford SportTrac Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I can't speak for either, I'm sure there are several that are similar. I have digital cable with a DVR. I record and watch what I want when I want, and I love it. all 3 of the kids have one too.
 
I have 2 replays.

Pros:

Connect to the LAN, and can share programs

Can run a program on your computer (DVArchive) to download shows. and store them

and also view shows from the computer.

can also record them to DVD

Cons:

Reboot problems About once a week or every 2 weeks.

Transfer of programs can be slow.

No HD recording



there are a few web sites I like.

www.planetreplay.com

www.DVArchive.com



Edit:

Only one of the replays need to be rebooted. going to upgrade to 200 gig HDs after the 90 warrantee and hope to get rid of that problem.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have not had the reboot problem that Sal has with my Replay.

TiVo has caught up over the last couple years, but I don't think they are there yet.
 
A stand-alone Tivo does all the features that Sal mentioned about the Replay unit.



I really don't care about networking or transferring the shows to my pc... I prefer my Directivo unit as it has 2 tuners, and records the shows direct off the satellite without any compression.
 
I just ordered Tivo on a deal where it's 16.95 a month instead of 12.95 & you get the 40hr series 2 box for free. Plus it's billed monthly instead the prepaid for a year deal.

Thanks for all your advice folks.
 
Scott:



1) The Tivo does make a short call at night, and I assume that info is what is passed anonymously to Directv. You can unplug the phone line and the unit will still work, although a daily screen will pop up to let you know to check your connection.



2) No ads display in the interface of either of my Directv units. There is a link to them in the menu if you want to view them.



The part I don't understand is why the DirecTivo requires a analog phone line. A lot of homes nowadays either just use cell phones or high speed internet.
 
Tonka ! please let Tivo use me as a refferal that would be great!



my email address is jmadderra - AT(@) - sbcglobal.net



anyone else interested please print out this free 30 day pass and include my email! what can us loose?[Broken External Image]:



I will gather the links i have for the 3rd party software i am using with the Tivo on our wireless network
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I just ordered ReplayTv also:)

The unit will be free after a rebate so I figured why not?

Now I guess I'll get to compare the Tivo & Replay first hand!

Whichever works out best for me I'll keep & give the other one to my son. (everyone wins)

Now I just gotta figure out how to hook these up to my wireless sattelite router thing because I have no regular phone service.:)
 
Tonka I think you can still call and still give them my email address....If not thats ok



You are going to LOVE your DVRs
 

Latest posts

Top